redfiona99: (11)
Doctor Who and the one with Vincent Van Gogh - needless to say, I loved it )

All of which makes me very cranky about Stephen Fry's comments that the BBC ought not to put all of it's eggs in the Merlin/Dr. Who family tv show bracket and ought to make TV for adults.

Because when was the last 'adult' TV show that made the very important point that you can't just hug away mental illness.

Doctor Who, The Fourth Doctor - The Sontaran Experiment - Decidedly Less Successful )

I find it interesting that a two-parter, so ~ 45 minutes, felt so short and lacking in comparison to a four-parter, i.e. 90 minutes, the length of today's two-parters. Is it any wonder that today's single parters sometimes feel so rushed? Then again, Old Who had it's own rhythm, which is a little slow for today. I quite like it, but then again, I work on a slow setting most days myself.
redfiona99: (Default)
Answers to the 5 things meme:

[livejournal.com profile] opera142 wanted 5 Ways Christian trumps Edge. )
~~~~

Precision in Everything Author's long-winded explanation/notes )

~~~~

Questions that need answers for future fic

1) US university years are divided up into semesters, yes?

and

2) Could anyone suggest a book likely to have been banned from school libraries for sexual content? I'd go with Lady Chatterly but I've been told it has all the eroticism of a dead fish and I need something that packs a punch.

~~~~

Doctor Who - Cold Blood

I prefer the use of actors in latex to CGI (let's be honest, I prefer most things to bad CGI, and that's the only kind of CGI that the BBC can afford) but it also has it's own drawbacks, mostly that it will occasionally throw up crazy-making moments of 'I know that actor, just not when he's green', and my brain spends half its time trying to ID the actor instead of watching what's on TV. It was Richard Hope who caused that effect this time, Stephen Moore at least has a distinctive voice (he'll always be the Dad in 'The Queen's Nose' to me.)

On to the actual episode.

Not as good as I thought it might be )

Some speculation about the big spoiler from Cold Blood, brought about by typing this up )

~~~~

After that, thanks to N and S, I got to watch some old school Who.

The Ark In Space )

~~~~

RL and Smear test TMI )
redfiona99: (10)
Well, I enjoyed that more than expected even though I'm now more than a bit Oh no not (spoiler) again )

But yes, I loved Tallulah and Frank, and Lazlo and Solomon, and I was even interested by Mr. Dialeg (or whatever his name was). And the thing was reasonably scary. We want there not to be more of those running around.

Sadly I then spoiled myself by watching some old Who and while it may have its problems, The Three Doctors especially, gosh wasn't it fun. I demand more fun in my Dr. Who.

Also the Three Doctors does feature that scene with Omega. And several that scenes with Benton and the Brig and I'm sorry but how can I not love it. The Androids of Tara was far more fun than it should have been, plus there were swords and the Prince/King was adorable and I enjoyed it immensely. There were also some classic lines and classic scenes and Lamia. It should be pointed out that it's a total Prisoner of Zenda rip-off, but since I love the Prisoner of Zenda, how could I not like it a lot too.

Didn't get to see all of the Ribos Operation, but the first half was interesting, particularly the Graf. Not sure I entirely like the White Guardian but that's possibly my own general dislike of authority figures coming out.

Torchwood

Nov. 22nd, 2006 02:49 pm
redfiona99: (torchwood)
Spoilers for Small Worlds and Countrycide )

And also (an edit) )

Then I watched the Pirate Planet and, sorry but no matter what I'll always love Old Skool Who more because, I'm sorry, but you can't tell a decent sci-fi story in 45 minutes, and Who works better as a serial.

That this was written by the esteemed Mr. Adams may also have helped.
redfiona99: (Dr. Who)
With apologies for that spelling of school.

I've been watching some old school Doctor Who, Tom Baker episodes and well, okay, I realise the SFX weren't as good, but I'll be damned if the stories weren't better. Okay, I may be being spoilt as one of the stories was 'City of Death', but even the other story, which was 'The Creature From the Pit', and more bog-standard sci-fi, was better sci-fi. Because that's one of the problems, even a really good episode like 'Love and Monsters' wasn't sci-fi, and the most wonderfully sci-fi idea of series 2, which was the Olympic alien, wasn't given time to develop. I'm one of those tiresome fans who wants more aliens and alien planets, because wasn't 'The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit' better because it was on an alien planet. Wouldn't it make more sense for a sci-fi show to spend money making Cardiff look like an alien world than making Cardiff look like London.

But yes, now for a spoiler cut for a show that aired before I was born )

But yes, in short, I enjoyed them both immensely.
redfiona99: (Default)
My family and I have done well, it's taken almost a week for me to reach seething anger.

I'm calm now. Possibly because 1) Austria won, admittedly another of their late, late shows but still they won 2-0 and 2) the new Doctor Who is so very good. Possibly helped by the way Russell T. Davies (yup the QAF guy and the man who's written the equally brilliant Cassanova series), as a fan, wrote something that had the same lovely balance the X-men movies have, enough to entice the geeks (Autons, he had Autons on his first show) and kept it open enough for a new audience to enjoy. I mean there's a possibility that I would have enjoyed it even more if it was a new series because I wouldn't have had the same worry about it living up to things past then.

Basic summary - Christopher Eccleston, though he might need to settle into it a little more, is a fun doctor, all childish enthusiams and very definitely and very subtly alien. And he's got the Dr. Who temper and lack of patience.
Billie Piper, not as bad as she could have been. Quite liked her in fact.
Storyline - worked.
SFX - better than expected but still with that down-at-home BBC charm (i.e. still more than a few moments of 'oh those effects are bad')

And the best bit, Dr. Who tried to reason with the bad guy. Yes, they've got it right - violence and destruction is always the last resort. Because this is Dr. Who we're talking about who passed up on the chance of totally destroying both his main enemies (the Master and the Daleks) because it would have been wrong. It sounds strange to say this, but Dr. Who has always been a very moral character, very much 'peace is good' and 'violence has to be the last option'.

Even if you're not a fan, take the time to watch 'Genesis of the Daleks' which is a Tom Baker episode dealing with the creation of the Daleks.

Spoilers beneath )
The rest of the story (it's 6 or 8 45-minute parts) is just as good. And something similar happens in Dr. Who and Minotaur or whatever it's called where he spares the life of the Master.

Oh yeah BTW, no matter what the 5th Doctor fans tell you, there is only one true incarnation of the Master and that's the one in the 3rd Doctor programmes. I think the actor's name is Roger Delgarno and he was being haughty, aloof, genius and charismatic evil while most of the good bad guys today were still in nappies.

Here's to hoping that Michael Grade doesn't find a way of cancelling it again.

Profile

redfiona99: (Default)
redfiona99

July 2025

S M T W T F S
  1 23 45
678 9 101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 12th, 2025 08:05 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios