redfiona99 (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
redfiona99) wrote2012-12-11 04:21 pm
redfiona99) wrote2012-12-11 04:21 pm
Star Trek Trailer
Mostly I am meh.
Let's be honest here, Cumberbund does not have the voice to do growly. Dear JJ et al., he can do plenty evil without growling.
Secondly
No, just no. At least 9/10ths of the punch of Wrath of Khan comes from having known those characters for years. You can't recapture that in two films. And killing off McCoy would also not work.
And if they're pretending this isn't a Khan re-hash, why are they making it look like one? Lying to your audience is not good. And unfortunately I have seen too many action movies to be impressed by generic stuff blowing up.
Let's be honest here, Cumberbund does not have the voice to do growly. Dear JJ et al., he can do plenty evil without growling.
Secondly
No, just no. At least 9/10ths of the punch of Wrath of Khan comes from having known those characters for years. You can't recapture that in two films. And killing off McCoy would also not work.
And if they're pretending this isn't a Khan re-hash, why are they making it look like one? Lying to your audience is not good. And unfortunately I have seen too many action movies to be impressed by generic stuff blowing up.